Opposing View | Why Josh Thomson Beat Gilbert Melendez

May 21, 2012 7:35 am by BJPENN.COM News


By Evan Stoumbelis
This past Saturday, fans saw Gilbert Melendez defend his Lightweight belt in a split-decision victory against Josh Thomson. This fight served as the rubber match for the two men, who split victories in their prior meetings.

The decision however, was a controversial one, with fans booing Melendez after he was declared the winner, and later on jumping in to support who they thought was the winner. Melendez even lashed out at a booing fan after the fight. Remember, just one week ago, Thomson was reported to have suffered a PCL tear, leaving everyone unsure of whether or not the fight would take place.

Thomson came into the fight looking like a man on a mission, he was aggressive and utilized his kickboxing in exchanges.  Especially front kicks and left head kicks, to stop Melendez from closing distance.  He scored a takedown in the first, and landed more strikes during exchanges, all while pushing the pace. In the fourth Thomson came very close to finishing Melendez with the rear naked choke at the end of the round but was unable to do so. In the fifth Thomson poured it out and left it all in the octagon, landing left head kicks, and flurries of punches, while securing takedowns.  Unfortunately, in MMA scoring, its not how you finish, because if that was the case Thomson would have won.

I gave rounds 1, 4 and 5 to Thomson, unfortunately the judges disagreed. What do you think PENNATION? who do you think deserved the win?

Read More: Thomson vs Melendez 4?

Anthony Pettis wants a fight with Nate Diaz

Nick Diaz suspended 1-year following NSAC hearing

Tags: , , , ,

About BJPENN.com

Shouted out after victory to the UFC masses, BJPENN.COM is the home to multiple time champion BJ Penn. After a decade of on-line operation BJPENN.COM has evolved into the most reliable destination for all your fighter interviews, fighter blogs and MMA/UFC news stories.

Advertise with us

For all advertising inquiries click here.

About us

Please contact us for all website inquiries.