BJPENN COM

MMA News

Monday, 02/13/2012, 08:22 am

Comments

MMA POLL: Should the UFC make teammates fight each other?


With the Georges St-Pierre vs. Carlos Condit match in the works as well as a light-heavyweight title fight between Jon Jones and Rashad Evans we wanted to ask the readers here on BJPENN.COM what you think of these teammate vs. teammate matchups. Sound off in our poll and head back here this Friday when we publish the results!

Read More: GSP vs. Condit, Evans vs. Jones, UFC

comments

56 Comments to MMA POLL: Should the UFC make teammates fight each other?

  1. Jb says:

    Its a jOb they should be forced to fight but on flip side. It may create boring fights and guys not going for the kill. There are plenty of the guys in the UFC that will fight I don’t see this being an issue unless a belt is involved

    • Ninja Oreo Dollop says:

      A good example of a horrible fight between friends was Frank Mir vs Roy Nelson.

    • whogivesash!7 says:

      plus, gsp fights out of Montreal, and might visit coach greg “point fighter” jackson in new mexico once in a while, so gsp and condit are not really team mates or friends. maybe acquainted? have they even rolled or spared with each other? probably not.

  2. Michael says:

    I don’t think team mates should be made to fight because if you train and someone for so long, it would end up being a boring fight if they know each others tendencies. Also, if they have the same trainers and coaches, it could create more problems and we’d see fighters at less than peak performance.

  3. Xaninho says:

    It’s basically an individual sport. Yes training together does make you better, but in the end if you’re in the same weightclass and you’re both good enough to go for the belt it’s bound to happen you have to fight eachother at some time in your career.

    It’s a bit different from tennisplayers or other individual sports, cause well…you’re basicaly expected to KO a close friend once the door shuts.

  4. anonymous says:

    I understand the flip side, but there is a good chance your teammates could be standing in the way of your progress through the rankings. It’s a job in the end and if you want to do better and progress you should fight whomever they line up for you. I don’t think they should be forced though. If they don’t want to fight a guy then they shouldn’t have to, but it could end up penalizing them. Jon Jones made the right choice way back when and it has certainly paid off.

  5. stone cold says:

    nick diaz won that fight!

  6. Jason says:

    i think today its much more of a reasonable option then it was years ago… the sport going back wasn’t really dominated by huge camps filled with top level fighters. everyone kinda came from their own camp, coaches, training partners, even the infamous jackson’s gym was relatively small and unknown boasting only really the likes of rashad, jardine, and a few others. nowadays everyone in the ufc also has a few training partners in the ufc because the sport is dominated by about 5 or 6 huge camps and a few smaller ones. with that landscape it is virtually impossible to keep having contenders without friends/teammates fighting each other. that being said, there is also no reason they shouldnt be able to fight each other. this is NOT a team sport. i was on track n field in highschool and every single meet was competing against people from my team. i know people that wrestled and often had to compete against their teammates at tournaments and invitationals. its competition. get in, fight, be friends again. on top of that with these huge camps there is guaranteed to be enough coaches and training partners for each fighter to utilize and they can just split into teams until the fight and all be friends theres no reason not to be professional about this. and if there isnt enough coaches or training partners the 2 fighters can come to an agreement weather it be via rock paper scissors or something else as to one moving temporarily to a diff camp for the upcoming fight.

  7. stone cold says:

    jon fitch and josh koshcheck suck ass

  8. Jujitsu Player says:

    I think they should have to fight whoever the UFC matches them with. It might not make the best fight but if you’re the number 1 contender and one of your friends/training partners is the champion you’ve got to take the fight.

  9. CALI says:

    JACKSON CAMP ONLY

  10. IAMSOAWESOME says:

    In the end everyone who fights in the UFC has the same goal, to be the CHAMP! So a teammate of yours shouldn’t stop you from achieving your goal/dream of becoming champ. When your in the cage it’s you and the person in-front of you only. Your coaches and teammates aren’t the ones throwing the punch and taking the punches. I’ve heard from a lot of fighters that the reason why they chose to become fighters over other sports was because it was not a team sport and you didn’t have to rely on others to perform and win.

  11. BobbyLemons says:

    A question…

    Has the UFC ever actually MADE teammates fight when they really didn’t want to?

  12. Dog chapman says:

    Bradda if I had for scrap beth for the ufc heavy wieght belt best belive bra I would give her the phalse crack medivak bra if she no drop I give her the 1 2 skip a few come in with the right uppah and garente bra crumble that broad make die dead bra pau hans

  13. Dog chapman says:

    Then buss my mace cuz I hard li dat

  14. baldy says:

    how is this such a big problem in mma and not in boxing. ya never here a boxer cryin about fighting a “teammate”.
    ali was larry homes’ mentor, and he beat the shit outta ali.

  15. TrigenicKin says:

    Not if they don’t want to.

  16. Pijan says:

    Yes. If someone has a belt it wouldn’t be right to not let someone fight them because they are their team mate. At the end of the day MMA isn’t a team sport. There aren’t rings or trophies for everyone else, there is one belt, one person holds it. If you want it and your team mate has it, you have to fight them.

  17. Armor V says:

    Of Course they should Fight, if your partner/friend is the Best and you’re Number 2 you have no choice… Look at Pride everyone almost trained with someone they fought eventually because it’s a tournament style match ups… They faced each other multiple times… that’s why they’re almost all friends…

  18. steeler says:

    to me its just a sport like eli and peyton play against each other maybe not fighting unless its for a title or title shot or if the fans just want it

  19. Matt says:

    Why would anybody want to see two friends fight? I don’t mean you gotta hate the other guy your fighting. But what fan wants to see guys fight and their heart is just not in it?

  20. bigg ass white boy says:

    yes they should fight each other …..but mma is a team sport no doubt about it not one single mma fighter fights,trains or corners by his or her self

  21. ry tay says:

    sure they should, why not?

  22. the original steve says:

    i really don’t think you should be forced to fight your teammates unless you want to. it can ruin friendships.

  23. chris says:

    Hell ya teammates should fight each other MMA is not a team sport. They need to quit being outlet bitches and fight you they are asked to. I’ll beat the shit out of my best friend for the right price

  24. cha c says:

    Never leave any fight in the hands of the judges,period.tired of hearing who should have won.yes same camp teamates should fight.

  25. SONNENISANIDIOT says:

    I see mma as an individual sport, anyways, sucks for the guys that like this ” teammate friend” idea,because for what I’ve seen, Dana doesn’t …

  26. Wait, what ? says:

    Since when has the UFC forced anyone to fight? If you dont want to fight your friend, dont take the fight, but dont cry when the promotion picks someone who is willing to fight for the prime time slots.

  27. tim says:

    Machida vs Silva for example… will never happen

  28. Shawn says:

    It’s a job, plain and simple. At the end of the day, your work for a company that requires you to fight whoever they match you up with. That’s your contract. If your truly friends, fighting each other because it’s your jobs, it won’t…shouldn’t affect your friendship. If it came down to it, I’d fight my brother to get a title shot, and he would me. We’d still be brothers, and he’d still be my best friend. And whoever wins, one would still be in the other’s corner.

    I think most fighters who say they would never fight their teammate, is because they are afraid they might lose because they know each others style and techniques too well. To me, that’s more of a challenge. Any fighter who can over come such challenge and still come out the victor, is a fighter to watch out for.

  29. Hightower says:

    I hope rory mcdonald vs gsp happens at some point in time.

  30. Brandon Wheaton says:

    Nah, let them put on full sparring gear and tap tap each other.

    Like I’m sure Condit & GSP will do.

  31. mikey says:

    Its competition. They should fight each other to see who is the best. I have to fight my friends to get better. Get over it. If anything it’ll make you train harder and leave it out on the line to prove you are better than your friend.

  32. jdog says:

    I admit that I have never liked fighting my friends but when working the smaller shows it happens all the time. If anything it makes for better fights since we both know each others weakness and go for it. It also helps when we know we have the other against the ropes we usually don’t throw extra punches that are not needed, take for instance the Hendo Bisping fight. That type of show would NEVER happen between team mates.

  33. BobO says:

    It’s like Eli not wanting to play Peyton in a future Superbowl. Get over it, you’re playing and you’re fighting. You don’t decide what the match ups are, The UFC does because they are paying you and running the show. With that being said, I wanna see Silva (at 205)vs Machida as soon as possible. Jon Jones can beat down Silva later on. ~BobO

  34. K2 says:

    I don’t think they should be MADE to. If they want to pass up the chance of advancing their carrer then that’s up to them. With the respect that a lot of fighters show each other I don’t see why one wouldn’t. Yeah, I understand that it could make some boring fights as you don’t wanna break your friend’s arm in the match, but two professional fighters should be able to fight each other in a professional manner. Consider it an advanced full contact sparring match. And now your teammate knows what to work on in practice (or help you work on).

  35. I think they should fight each other, they are professionals after all

    • jdog says:

      no one is MADE to ever fight, if the boss tells you to do something you have two options (depending if what he wants you to do is legal or not) you either do what your boss says, or you quit, that simple enough said on the subject. If you don’t want to fight your friends then don’t fight for the same organization or get over it.

  36. No not each other, they should be tag-teamates. This is
    a concept at the at the cxcpro.com website

  37. Marshall says:

    THEY SHOULD EITHER BE TAG-TEAMATES OR IF THAT IS NOT
    POPULAR YET THEN THEY SHOULD HAVE TO FIGHT EACH OTHER
    BECAUSE IT’S A BUSINESS. SO SPIDER AND JONES SHOULD FIGHT.

  38. Matt says:

    Who wants to see a fight with two guys that aren’t motivated to go at each other. Not me. I know fighting is business, but if two guys are like brothers to one another, you may get a sparring session instead.

  39. dukeofhardrock says:

    I don’t think its necessary to HAVE to fight your friend or team mate, it would put a huge strain on the team that would more often than not end in tears, although this is a professional sport but also not a team sport I wouldn’t like to face a friend in the octagon, also chances are the fights wouldn’t have 100% commitment from either fighter

  40. mean170 says:

    Maybe not for a regular match-up, but for a no.1 contender or a title fight then of course. I don’t see any fighter turning down a title shot just cause a training partner is the Champ.

  41. the original+steve says:

    all you guys need to train with a team almost every day and then be forced to fight them. its not right. people you train with you are probably around them more than your own family. you team becomes your family and to fight one of them is just fucked up. and coaches dont want to coach 2 fighters to fight each other. and its notlike you want to leave your team just to fight one of your best friends. so all you people who say they should be forced to “i want you to go to your bedroom, take your shoes off, lie down in your bed, take about 20 or 30 minutes, and go fuck yourself”

    • mean170 says:

      You’d give up a title shot if one of your friends had the belt? Not likely. I doubt Dana has to force people into fights anyways.

      • the original+steve says:

        see the question was. should ufc force them that i have a problem with. i got no problem if u wanna fight ur team. and idk what i would do in that situation i would talk to the belt holder and my coach and see what they think and go from there

    • jdog says:

      When have you trained or fought in MMA? I have and I HAVE had to fight my team mates. You would not believe how many friends have to fight one another in the smaller shows. Think about it, a show like rage in the cage goes to bum f#ck egypt and they want 10 fights, they have 5 fights already lined up and are going to fill the other 5 with local talent, and guess what once again you are in BFE so you might have 4 in the same weight class so guess what you either don’t fight or you fight a friend. I have had to do it 3 times, each time they were good fights that were finished, twice quickly and the other went half way through the third. ( I won 2 of the 3) after the fight we went out and had a good time together, the next day we started training at the gym together once again. It wasn’t personal and in fact my friend is lucky I was the one that fought him 25 seconds in I dropped him and I knew he was out, instead of jumping on him and punching I simply followed him to the ground (to make sure he wasn’t faking) I looked up at the ref and he waved it off, had it been another fighter he would have surely ate at least 5 extra punches

  42. Dakota says:

    They should have to, it wouldnt be fair to tell someone they cant fight for the title just cause thier friend holds the title

  43. MMA_Kid says:

    I don’t think they should be made to fight each other but like in the Fitch vs Kos situation their both top 4 welters so eventually they’re gonna have to fight for a title shot.

  44. drew says:

    yes, u wake up as a kid wanting to be the champion,u dont dream about training with your buddies. u dream about being the best at your division or of all time so its really whether you wanna be a real man, which is doing things in life u dont wanna do but have to do to achieve your goals or just be a pussy. Choose one. I choose beating a teammate whether it be ko or sub or dec, and at the end of the day if i was the one to be beat i would wake up a lil confused and a lil pissed off but then id be seeing my buddy wearing the belt, so ya know thats when u gotta be a man again realize u lost and congratulate your friend. Its part of the sport

  45. Matt paccaro says:

    Ho yupp my name is matt paccarro I take it in the but like a champ I can handle four cocks at once hit me up plz no privates ccalls serious ppl only I want a toughg mma guy to toss my ass around perferably blacks only 8083485686

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>